I often hear “I have X% bounces. How do I compare against
benchmarks?” I have a theory on this, when it comes to negative metrics such as
bounce don’t benchmark yourself against others. We are going in the direction
where data integrity is key, where subscribers are being given the tools to manage
their inboxes; where relevancy of marketing communications and subscriber
engagement is a contributing factor to filtering.
How do I measure against benchmarking for bounces...
Why am I so against purchased data?
So people ask... “Why are you so against purchased data”?
Well, this is why...
[Please note: I have kept brands and senders anonymous]
A while back I
started receiving spam [third party newsletters] from “Brand A”. “Brand A” are
owned by “Company A”. So I emailed them and mentioned that I make a point of
not allowing my data to be used for third party mailings and asked to confirm
opt in details of my address.
They thanked me for
getting in touch and“unsubscribed” me from their database so I wouldn’t receive
anymore emails. They also admitted working with certain data partners where
I would have opted in for third party offers, however, within 48 hours they’d
confirm where I opted in.
After not hearing
back from “Company A” I then received an email from “Company B” saying they had
been passed my details with regards to an issue I had with receiving a
marketing message in the last few days. Having not encountered “Company B” before;
I wanted to see where they got my data from. So it turns out “Company B”
received the request from “Company C” who have asked them to have a look at my
marketing message issue.
At this point in my
investigation to find the source of this SPAM I am left thinking how have I
jumped from “Company A” to “Company B” and who are “Company C”? My assumption
now is that “Company B” provided the email address to “Company C” who in turn
sold my address to “Company A”...
Confused? Have
I already painted the picture of why purchased data is bad? The next part is even worse...
It turns out “Company
B” are a mobile marketing company rather than email marketing and as such have
a database of mobile numbers that they allow companies to check against for
TPS, Network Blacklisting, Quarantined numbers etc, and some of these rows contain
email address. In this case the email address has been used for marketing
rather than its intended use; as part of a blacklisted file. They referred to
this as a “simply a manual error on our part”.
How is selling
blacklisted contact details a simple error?
Their cleansing
files are direct from the mobile networks and 3rd party data cleansers, every 3
months or so they pass all companies with mobile connections a list of mobile
users that are in the following lists; TPS, Network Blacklisting, Quarantined
numbers and used STOP commands on keywords/shortcodes associated with their
company. I apparently could rest assured that your email address has only left
our company in this one case.
IMO that depends on who that one case was, by this point it
been in the hands of two other companies.
Re-enter “Brand A”;
I haven’t received spam from them for a while now however after receiving more
spam, I obviously questioned my previous “unsubscribe” and was told they did
unsubscribe me however tech noticed my details were merged into a new database.
I was then told I have been successfully unsubscribed.
14 Days late
re-enter “Brand A” with a MacMillan email. I am spun [what I think was] a blatant LIE.
They “suppressed” my details from all their files when we communicated and
haven't sent me any emails since. They went on to say below email is from
another company/person who is falsely using their details. REALLY, are they falsely sending your creative, or are you getting
someone else to send your creative and now trying to pull the wools over the
eyes of an email savvy person after another “mistake”?
Two months roll on
and enter “CompanyD”. Spam’s from a car manufacturer
and global credit card company... The source URL: www.”Brand A”.co.uk having read
this blog you’ll know I didn't sign up from their site in June, they brought my
data from someone who scrapped it off the TPS!
This is the
precise reason why purchased lists are NEVER a good idea. Rant Over!
The Proactive Marketer
http://hitw.se/NNWr8g
London 2012 is coming...
In the build up to the games the likes of BT and Coca-Cola are using the tickets they get through sponsorship deals to lure people to giving away their precious details in return for a small chance of going to the games, I am starting to wonder, with the ruckus of the original ticket scandals (I mean sales) where masses of people were left ticketless, will this cause companies deliverability issues.